10 Things to Avoid when you Sell on ETSY as a Beginners

Hey there! It’s Anu from the DuoThrivers team.

Opening an Etsy shop is exciting. You list your first product, refresh your dashboard every hour, and wait for that first “Cha-ching!”

And then… nothing.

If that sounds familiar, don’t worry. Most new Etsy sellers go through this. And most of the time, the problem isn’t the product. It’s a few common beginner mistakes that quietly hold the shop back.

We work with a lot of Etsy sellers through our Pinterest agency, ThriversEdge, and we see the same issues come up again and again.

So in this post, we’ve listed 10 things to avoid when you sell on Etsy as a beginner, plus what to do instead.

Let’s get started!


1. Pricing Without Counting Etsy’s Fees

This is the number one mistake we see.

Beginners look at what others charge, pick a similar price, and forget that Etsy takes a cut of every sale.

In the US, Etsy’s main fees are:

  • $0.20 listing fee per item (renews every four months or when it sells)
  • 6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping
  • 3% + $0.25 payment processing fee
  • Offsite Ads fee of 15% (12% for shops above $10,000 in yearly sales) on sales that come from Etsy’s ads on other sites

On a $10 item, standard fees can eat more than 12% of your sale. Add materials, packaging and shipping, and some beginners are actually losing money on every order.

What to do instead:

  • Work out your true cost per item (materials, packaging, fees, your time).
  • Price for profit, not just to match others.
  • If you’re under $10,000 in yearly sales, decide whether to opt out of Offsite Ads in your shop settings.

2. Selling Things You Don’t Have the Rights To

Disney characters, sports team logos, famous quotes from movies, popular cartoon characters, brand names… these all sell, which is exactly why so many beginners try them.

But using trademarked or copyrighted material without permission can get your listings removed and your shop suspended.

What to do instead: Create original designs. If you’re unsure, search the term on the USPTO trademark database before you use it.


3. Ignoring Etsy’s Creativity Standards

Etsy wants every item to be made, designed, sourced or handpicked by the seller. Each listing is labeled one of these ways:

  • Made by – physical items you make yourself
  • Designed by – your original designs, including digital downloads and items produced by a production partner (like print on demand)
  • Sourced by – craft supplies and party items that help buyers create
  • Handpicked by – vintage items

Reselling mass-produced items isn’t allowed, and Etsy has been actively removing listings that break these rules.

What to do instead: Read Etsy’s Creativity Standards before you list. If you use a print-on-demand partner like Printify or Printful, make sure your listing shows it correctly.


4. Writing Titles Full of Keywords

A lot of older Etsy advice told you to stuff your title with every keyword you could think of.

That doesn’t work well anymore. Etsy’s current guidance is to keep titles clear and readable, with the most important words at the start, because mobile shoppers only see the first part.

Bad: Mom Gift Mothers Day Gift Mom Necklace Gift for Mom Birthday Gift Necklace Mom

Better: Personalized Birthstone Necklace for Mom, Sterling Silver Family Name Necklace

What to do instead: Describe the item clearly in the title. Put occasion and recipient words (like “Mother’s Day” or “gift for her”) in your tags and description.


5. Not Using All 13 Tags

Etsy gives you 13 tags per listing, each up to 20 characters. Every empty tag is a missed chance to be found.

What to do instead:

  • Use all 13.
  • Use multi-word phrases (“boho wall art”, “new mom gift”) instead of single words.
  • Cover different ways people search: style, occasion, recipient, material, use.
  • Don’t repeat the same phrase in multiple tags.

6. Using Poor Photos

Buyers can’t touch your product. Your photos are your salesperson.

Dark, blurry, cluttered photos make even great products look cheap.

What to do instead:

  • Use natural light near a window.
  • Make your first photo clean and simple, with one item.
  • Add lifestyle photos, close-ups, size comparisons and a short video.
  • Use photos at least 2000 pixels wide and high, as Etsy recommends.

7. Launching With Just 2 or 3 Listings

A shop with two items looks unfinished, and it gives Etsy very few chances to show you in search.

Etsy itself recommends starting with at least 10 listings.

What to do instead: Launch with 10 or more listings, then keep adding new ones regularly. Variations of a best-seller (different colors, sizes, themes) count too.


8. Skipping Shop Basics

Empty “About” sections, no shop announcement, no policies, no profile photo… these small things make buyers hesitate.

What to do instead:

  • Add a profile photo and a short “About” story.
  • Fill in your shop policies (returns, processing time, shipping).
  • Set realistic processing times so you don’t miss deadlines.
  • Reply to messages quickly.

9. Relying Only on Etsy for Traffic

Etsy has millions of buyers, but it also has millions of sellers. As a new shop with no reviews, it’s hard to get seen in search at first.

Many beginners just wait, hoping Etsy will send buyers.

What to do instead: Bring your own traffic. And for Etsy sellers, Pinterest is one of the best places to do that.

People use Pinterest to plan gifts, parties and home makeovers, often weeks in advance. A good Pin can keep sending visitors to your listing for months.

Here’s how to start:

  1. Create a Pinterest business account and claim your Etsy shop.
  2. Find keywords buyers use with our Pinterest keyword research guide.
  3. Create several Pins for each product.
  4. Pin consistently, a few fresh Pins every day.

Our full guide on using Pinterest to boost Etsy sales covers this step by step.

🎨 Free Pin templates for your Etsy shop

Grab our 10 free editable Canva Pin templates. Add your product photos, change the text, and start pinning.

Want more variety? Get our 60 Premium Canva Pinterest Pin Templates for $19.

📌 Want an expert to look at your Pinterest?

Our ThriversEdge team offers a $99 Pinterest account audit with a clear list of fixes, 15 keywords for your niche, and 60 Canva Pin templates. Or let us design and schedule your Pins for you.

👉 Get your Pinterest audit or book a free strategy call.


10. Giving Up Too Soon

Many new shops take a few weeks, or even a couple of months, to get the first sale. That’s normal.

The sellers who succeed aren’t always the most talented. They’re the ones who keep listing, keep improving photos and titles, and keep promoting while others quit.

What to do instead:

  • Give your shop at least 3 to 6 months of consistent effort.
  • Check your Etsy stats every couple of weeks. Which listings get views but no sales? Improve their photos and price. Which get no views? Improve their titles and tags.
  • Plan for seasonal peaks like Mother’s Day, Easter and Christmas, and list seasonal items 6 to 8 weeks early.

RELATED: How to Make Money on Etsy in 2027: 7 Steps to Start


Bonus: Mistakes With Physical Products

  • Not weighing packages. Wrong shipping weights can wipe out your profit. A cheap kitchen or shipping scale fixes this.
  • Charging too much for shipping. Many buyers are put off by high shipping costs. Consider building some shipping into your item price.
  • Ignoring safety rules for kids’ products. In the US, toys, children’s clothing and baby items have CPSC requirements. Read the CPSC guide for online sellers before you list.

Should You Also Build Your Own Website?

Not on day one. But once you have steady sales, a simple website helps you:

  • Sell without marketplace fees
  • Build an email list of past customers
  • Protect your business if Etsy changes its rules

When you’re ready, follow our guide to setting up a WordPress site. We host all our sites on Hostinger.

We may earn a commission if you sign up through this affiliate link, at no extra cost to you. See Hostinger’s current hosting plans.


FAQs

How long does it take to get the first sale on Etsy?

It varies. Some shops sell in the first week, while many take a few weeks or a couple of months. More listings, better photos and outside traffic (like Pinterest) help speed it up.

Is it worth selling on Etsy in 2027?

Yes, if you treat it like a business: price for profit, follow Etsy’s rules, list consistently and bring your own traffic.

Should I opt out of Etsy Offsite Ads?

If your shop makes under $10,000 a year, you can opt out. It depends on your margins. If a 15% fee on an ad-driven sale would leave you with little or no profit, opting out may make sense.


Final Words

And that’s it!

Every successful Etsy seller made at least a few of these mistakes when they started. The difference is that they learned quickly and kept going.

Fix your pricing, follow the rules, polish your listings, and bring your own traffic with Pinterest. Your first sale is closer than you think.

Want our exact Pinterest process? Get the free Pinterest strategy guide.

Good luck, Thrivers!

Want to Earn $500 with Pinterest?

Subscribe to get our latest content by email.

    Choose One

    Grab this free 3-month action plan and learn how to grow a brand-new Pinterest account from zero to $500 – even if you're just starting out.

    Note: Some of the links on this page are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you choose to make a purchase through them-at no extra cost to you. We only recommend products and services we genuinely believe in and find useful.